I can’t find them, but I can still picture them, sitting in a bag on the floor of my old bedroom, about twenty or so, most containing my own block print and notations like “acoustic version”. (“Who says ‘acoustic’ now?” asked my best friend. “It’s ‘unplugged,’ you know.”). I’ve searched my parents’ attic, vainly hoping that they were saved along with the Strawberry Shortcake dolls and class projects, not simply discarded when my bedroom became a home office. I’d swap my entire iTunes library for these missing glimpses of me at sixteen, seventeen, twenty.
Blues and bootlegs from a high school crush, his sloppy boyish cursive giving me a secret thrill. Another that my old boyfriend mailed to my dorm room, a year or so after we broke up (the accompanying note read: “why am I still afraid of your dad?”). “I’ve Grown Accustomed to Her Face” was easy enough, but was I overanalyzing that Operation Ivy song? And I hated to admit, you had to hand it to a guy who could mix Tony Bennett and punk and make the whole thing seamless. My freshman roommate decorated her contribution to my collection with a collage that slid between the case and the liner; an ingenious move that I copied for every mix tape I produced thereafter. Inside was a microcosm of nineties girl cool, from Ani DiFranco to the Murmurs.
Then there are ones given in grateful exchange, crafted during afternoons spent hunkered down at the stereo in an endless cycle of record-rewind-record-rewind, trying to cramp “Subterranean Homesick Blues” on one of those tiny lines with a fine tip pen. I want them back, want to ask everyone to check their parents’ attics. A lost cause, I know; also gone is the perfect jogging companion (some Alice in Chains, Archers of Loaf) that I borrowed and then so foolishly returned to my college boyfriend. I ended up marrying the guy, and he came with a silver pick-up and a few pieces of furniture but no mix tapes.
It’s OK, I guess. Really, what would I do with a bag of old cassettes? My car doesn’t even have a tape player. As though technological developments deliberately kept pace with my own, CD-Rs slowly began to replace mix tapes toward the end of college; the computer I purchased my senior year came with a CD burner. Yet it went unused. I have a few random mix CDs, but their typed sticky labels and printed liners leave me cold. But perhaps in another few years, I’ll wax nostalgic about those as CDs become the quaint precursors to all else digital. Just in case, I’ve got them safely stored away.
